SPDs: Not Just One & Done ⚡

It’s 2 AM on a Tuesday. Your phone buzzes on the nightstand, and the caller ID is the plant’s night shift supervisor. Your heart sinks. It’s never good news. A thunderstorm rolled through the area an hour ago, but it was miles away—no direct hits, not even a flicker in the lights at your house. But the supervisor’s voice is frantic. “Line 3 is down. The main PLC, two VFDs, and half the I/O cards are fried. We’re completely dead in the water.”

I’ve been a senior application engineer for over 15 years, and I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard a variation of this story. The culprit isn’t the storm itself, but the invisible killer it sends down the power lines: a transient overvoltage, or what we commonly call a power surge. It’s a high-energy, short-duration electrical spike that can cripple or destroy sensitive electronics in a microsecond. The cost isn’t just the few thousand dollars for a new PLC; it’s the tens or hundreds of thousands in lost production, missed deadlines, and emergency repair costs.

Most facilities believe they’re protected because they have an external lightning rod system. But that only protects the building’s structure from a direct fire-starting strike. It does nothing to stop the massive electrical surges that are conducted and induced into your power, data, and communication lines.

This is where Surge Protective Devices (SPDs) come in. But the question I hear most often is, “Which ones do I need? And where? Should I put SPDs on every panel?” The answer isn’t just “yes” or “no.” The right answer is a strategic one, rooted in understanding the different types of SPDs and the technologies inside them. This guide will walk you through the why, what, and where of surge protection, from the service entrance to the most sensitive piece of equipment on your floor, focusing on a deep material comparison between Type 1 vs Type 2 vs Type 3 SPD.

The Fundamentals: How Does a Surge Protector Work?

Before we dive into the different types, let’s clarify what an SPD actually does. Think of your electrical system as a plumbing system with a steady, normal water pressure (voltage). A surge is like a sudden, massive water hammer blast—a spike in pressure that can burst pipes and damage appliances.

Un SPD acts like a pressure-relief valve. Under normal voltage conditions, it sits there, doing nothing, presenting a high impedance. But when it detects a voltage spike above a certain threshold (its clamping voltage), it instantly creates a very low-impedance path to divert that excess energy safely to the ground. Once the voltage returns to normal, the “valve” closes again. This all happens in nanoseconds.

Surges come from two primary sources:

1. External Surges: These are the big ones, often caused by lightning strikes (even miles away) or utility grid switching operations. They carry immense energy and are the primary threat to your main electrical service.
2. Internal Surges: These are far more common, accounting for up to 80% of all transient events. They are generated inside your own facility every time large loads like motors, pumps, HVAC systems, or welders switch on and off. While smaller in magnitude, their constant repetition degrades electronics over time, leading to what seems like random, premature failure.

Because these threats come from both outside and inside, a single surge protector is not enough. The most effective strategy is a coordinated, layered approach known as “defense in depth.” Imagine it like a water filtration system: a coarse screen at the intake catches the big rocks, a finer filter downstream catches the sediment, and a final carbon filter at the tap ensures the water is pure. SPDs work in the same cascaded way.SPDs: Not Just One & Done

A layered, or cascaded, surge protection system.

The SPD Hierarchy: A Deep Dive into Type 1 vs Type 2 vs Type 3 SPD

The industry, guided by standards like UL 1449 and the IEC 62305 series, has classified SPDs into “Types” based on where they are installed and the kind of surge they are designed to handle. Understanding this Type 1 vs Type 2 vs Type 3 SPD hierarchy is the foundation of a robust protection plan.

Type 1 SPD: The Frontline Defender

A Type 1 SPD is your system’s first line of defense. It’s the heavy-duty gatekeeper installed at the service entrance, right where power from the utility enters your building. It can be installed on either the “line side” (before the main breaker) or “load side” (after the main breaker), but its primary job is to tackle the most powerful external surges.

• Location: Main service entrance, main switchboard, or utility transformer.
• Purpose: To protect against high-energy transients from direct or nearby lightning strikes and major utility switching events.
• Key Spec: A Type 1 SPD is defined by its ability to withstand a 10/350µs current waveform, referred to as its impulse current (Iimp). This waveform simulates the massive energy and long duration of a direct lightning current. Think of it as being built to withstand a tidal wave.
• Pro-Tip: If your building has an external lightning protection system (lightning rods), a Type 1 SPD is not just recommended—it’s essential. The lightning protection system is designed to safely conduct a direct strike to the ground, but in doing so, it will induce a massive surge onto your electrical system that only a Type 1 device is rated to handle.

Type 2 SPD: The Workhorse of Your Facility

A Type 2 SPD is the most common type you’ll find, protecting your sub-panels and distribution boards throughout a facility. It’s designed to be installed on the “load side” of an overcurrent protection device (like a circuit breaker).

• Location: Distribution panels, branch panels, and sensitive equipment feeds.
• Purpose: To divert the residual surge energy “let through” by the Type 1 SPD upstream, and more importantly, to clamp the frequent surges generated within your own facility.
• Key Spec: Type 2 SPDs are tested using an 8/20µs current waveform, known as the nominal discharge current (In). This waveform has a much faster rise time and shorter duration than the 10/350µs wave, simulating the characteristics of internally generated surges and the remnants of external ones. Think of these as handling the choppy, unpredictable waves inside the harbor after the main tidal wave has been broken by the sea wall.

Type 3 SPD: The Final Polish at Point-of-Use

A Type 3 SPD is the final layer of protection, located right next to the equipment it’s protecting. These are the devices you see in surge-protected power strips, plug-in adapters, or sometimes built directly into sensitive electronics.

• Location: At the outlet or equipment connection, typically within 10 meters (about 30 feet) of the load.
• Purpose: To clamp the small, fast transients that can still make it past the Type 2 SPD or that are generated by nearby devices. Their main advantage is providing a very low clamping voltage right where it’s needed most.
• Key Spec: Type 3 devices are also tested with an 8/20µs current wave, but their focus is less on massive energy handling and more on a low Voltage Protection Rating (VPR) ou Niveau de protection de la tension (vers le haut). This rating tells you the maximum voltage the equipment will be exposed to, and for sensitive electronics, lower is always better.
• Pro-Tip: Never rely on a Type 3 SPD alone! It’s like using a coffee filter to stop a flood. Without the upstream Type 1 and Type 2 devices to handle the heavy lifting, a large surge will instantly destroy a Type 3 device and the equipment it’s supposed to be protecting.

Feature Comparison: Type 1 vs Type 2 vs Type 3

Inside the Box: A Material Comparison of SPD Technologies

So, what’s actually inside these devices that allows them to perform these high-speed feats of electrical engineering? The SPD “Type” defines its application, but the component technology inside is what does the real work. The choice of material dictates the device’s performance, lifespan, and cost. There are four main components you’ll find, often used in hybrid combinations.

1. Metal Oxide Varistor (MOV)

The MOV is the undisputed workhorse of the surge protection world, found in the vast majority of Type 2 and Type 3 SPDs. It’s a ceramic semiconductor device (primarily zinc oxide with other metal oxides) that acts like a voltage-sensitive switch. At normal voltages, its grain boundaries create a high resistance. When the voltage shoots up, these boundaries break down in nanoseconds, and the resistance drops to near zero, shunting the surge current to ground.

• Pros: Very fast response time, high energy absorption capability for its size, and relatively inexpensive.
• Cons: They degrade with each surge they divert. Each event slightly alters the material, lowering its clamping voltage. Over time, they can fail, sometimes in a short-circuit condition. This is why all modern SPDs with MOVs MUST include thermal fusing and status indicators to disconnect them safely at end-of-life.

2. Gas Discharge Tube (GDT)

A GDT is a simple but powerful device consisting of two or more electrodes sealed in a small ceramic tube filled with an inert gas. When the voltage across the electrodes exceeds the gas’s breakdown voltage, an arc forms, creating an extremely low-resistance path (a virtual short circuit).

• Pros: Can handle extremely high surge currents (making them ideal for lightning-level events in Type 1 applications), very low capacitance (excellent for data/telecom lines), and they are very robust, not degrading with use in the same way MOVs do.
• Cons: They are slower to react than MOVs. When they do trigger, the arc creates what is known as “follow current”—it will continue to conduct even after the surge has passed, as long as the line voltage is sufficient to maintain the arc. This can be disruptive on AC power lines and often requires a secondary component (like an MOV or fuse) to extinguish the arc.

3. Spark Gap

A spark gap is the original “brute force” surge protector. In its simplest form, it’s just two conductors separated by a small air gap. When a very high voltage occurs (like from lightning), an arc jumps the gap, diverting the current. Modern “triggered spark gaps” are more advanced versions that use a third electrode or electronic circuit to fire more reliably and at lower, more controlled voltages.

• Pros: Can handle the highest levels of lightning current imaginable (Iimp > 100 kA). They are incredibly robust.
• Cons: Very slow, imprecise trigger voltage, and generates a significant follow current that must be extinguished, usually by a fuse or breaker. They are almost exclusively found in heavy-duty Type 1 SPDs at utility substations or main service entrances where brute force is the priority.

4. Transient Voltage Suppression (TVS) Diode

TVS diodes are semiconductor devices, like super-fast Zener diodes, designed specifically for surge protection. They are the precision instruments of the SPD world, clamping voltage with surgical accuracy.

• Pros: Extremely fast response time (picoseconds), very precise clamping voltage, and they don’t degrade with repeated use (within their rating).
• Cons: They have a much lower energy handling capability compared to the other technologies. They are perfect for protecting sensitive board-level components and are often used as the final stage of protection in Type 3 devices.

Material Technology Matrix: At-a-Glance Comparison

Key Takeaway: The perfect SPD often isn’t about a single technology, but a hybrid design that leverages the strengths of each. A common and highly effective combination in a high-performance Type 1 or Type 2 SPD is a GDT or Spark Gap for massive energy handling, paired with an MOV to manage the response time and clamping voltage, ensuring both brute force protection and fast, precise clamping.

From Theory to Practice: A 3-Step Selection and Installation Guide

Now for the most important part: how do you apply all this to your facility? A good design follows a clear, logical process.

Step 1: Understand Your Protection Zones (LPZ Concept)

The IEC 62305 standard introduces the concept of Lightning Protection Zones (LPZ). Think of your building as a series of nested boxes, with each layer providing more protection. Your goal is to install an SPD at the boundary of each zone transition to progressively reduce the surge energy.

The Lightning Protection Zone (LPZ) concept, showing SPD placement at zone boundaries.

• LPZ 0: Outside the building, exposed to direct lightning and the full electromagnetic field.
• LPZ 1: The area just inside the building, after the first protective device (Type 1 SPD).
• LPZ 2: Deeper within the building, after a secondary protective device (Type 2 SPD).
• LPZ 3: The immediate area around a sensitive device, protected by a final device (Type 3 SPD).

Step 2: The SPD Selection Decision Tree

Use this simple tree to guide your selection process.

Step 3: Four Key Installation Checks

I’ve seen multi-thousand-dollar SPD systems rendered useless by sloppy installation. Physics is unforgiving. Follow these rules religiously.

1. Correct Location: Place the SPD as close to the panel or equipment it is protecting as possible.
2. Short Lead Lengths: This is the single most important installation rule. The wires connecting the SPD to the panel’s phases and ground bar add inductance. Every inch of wire increases the let-through voltage during a fast-rising surge. The voltage added can be hundreds of volts per foot! Pro-Tip: Keep lead lengths under 0.5 meters (about 20 inches) at all costs. Twist the phase and ground wires together to reduce the inductive loop.
3. Solid Grounding: The SPD’s job is to divert energy to the ground. If your grounding system is poor (high resistance), the energy has nowhere to go, and the SPD cannot do its job. Ensure you have a single, low-impedance ground reference.
4. Proper Overcurrent Protection: SPDs need to be connected via a circuit breaker or fuse. This is NOT to protect the SPD from surges, but to safely disconnect it from the power source in the rare event of an end-of-life failure, preventing a fire hazard. Always follow the manufacturer’s recommendation for the size of this breaker.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Can I just install a Type 3 SPD (like a power strip) and skip the bigger ones?
No. This is a common and costly mistake. A Type 3 device is only designed to handle small, residual surges. A large surge from the utility or a nearby lightning strike will destroy it and likely the equipment connected to it. It needs the upstream Type 1 and Type 2 devices to reduce the surge to a manageable level.

2. How do I know if my surge protector needs to be replaced?
Most modern panel-mounted SPDs (Type 1 and 2) have a status indicator light or a mechanical flag. Green typically means it’s working; red, off, or a different color means the protection has been compromised and the unit needs replacement. Some advanced systems also have remote monitoring contacts that can tie into your building management system.

3. What is the difference between a surge protector and a circuit breaker?
A circuit breaker protects against overcurrent—a condition where the system draws too much current for a sustained period (e.g., a short circuit or an overloaded motor). It’s a slow-acting thermal-magnetic device. An SPD protects against overvoltage—an extremely fast, short-duration voltage spike. They serve two completely different but equally important protective functions.

4. Will a surge protector protect my equipment from a direct lightning strike?
No device can offer 100% protection from a direct strike on the structure itself. A properly installed Lightning Protection System (LPS) handles the direct strike. A Type 1 SPD is designed to handle the immense current that gets conducted onto the power lines from that strike. They are two parts of a complete system.

5. Is a higher kA rating always better?
To a point. A higher kA rating (for Iimp or In) means the device can handle more surge energy or more surge events over its lifetime, so it generally indicates a more robust and longer-lasting device. However, once you have an adequate kA rating for your exposure level, a lower Voltage Protection Rating (VPR) or Up becomes the more critical factor for protecting sensitive electronics.

6. Why are installation lead lengths so important?
Inductance. Every centimeter of wire has inductance, which resists a rapid change in current (like a surge). This resistance creates a voltage drop along the wire. During a surge, this voltage adds to the SPD’s clamping voltage, increasing the total voltage seen by your equipment. Short, straight wires minimize this added voltage.

7. Do I need SPDs in an area with infrequent thunderstorms?
Yes. Remember that up to 80% of surges are generated internally. Every time a motor, compressor, or VFD cycles, it creates a small surge. Utility grid switching also happens everywhere. These events cause cumulative damage that reduces the lifespan and reliability of your electronic assets.

8. Can I install a panel-mounted SPD myself?
Unless you are a qualified and licensed electrician, you should not. Installation involves working inside live or potentially live electrical panels, which is extremely dangerous. For safety, compliance, and effectiveness, always hire a professional.

Conclusion: So, Should You Put SPDs on Every Panel?

Let’s return to our original question. The answer is not to blindly put an SPD on every panel, but to install a strategically chosen SPD at every critical transition point in your electrical system.

This means:

1. Starting with a brute-force Type 1 device at the service entrance to handle the tidal waves from outside.
2. Adding workhorse Type 2 devices at key distribution panels that feed sensitive or critical machinery to handle the choppy waves inside.
3. Finishing with precision Type 3 devices to protect the most vulnerable control, data, and microprocessor-based equipment.

By understanding the difference in the Type 1 vs Type 2 vs Type 3 SPD debate, digging into the material comparisons of MOV, GDT, and other technologies, and implementing a coordinated, multi-layered surge protection strategy—designed with care and installed with precision—you can turn a story of catastrophic failure into a non-event. The lights might flicker, but your critical systems will stay online, and you’ll get to sleep soundly through the next storm.